top of page

ABOUT US

GET TO KNOW
OUR AGENCY

Originally established in 1935 by Ralph L. Humphrey and later carried forward by his son, our agency has built a lasting reputation for dependable coverage, high standards, and friendly, personalized service. Today, under the leadership of our new owner, Tony Cusati, we continue that tradition with the same commitment to the people and businesses of Ashtabula, OH, and beyond. With years of insurance experience and a dedicated team behind him, Tony is proud to help carry forward the service and trust our clients have come to rely on. Whether you’ve been with us for years or are purchasing insurance for the first time, we look forward to serving you.

At our agency,  we believe you deserve top-quality service and personalized attention, which is why we're committed to delivering our very best every step of the way. From finding the right coverage to uncovering every available discount, we're here to ensure you have peace of mind knowing what matters most is well protected. ... MORE

PROS AT YOUR SERVICE.

Tony Cusati

President

I grew up in Reading, Pennsylvania, and made Erie my home in 2009. I earned my Bachelor’s degree in Accounting from...

michael.png

Stephanie Carroll

Licensed Agent and Office Manager

With more than 30 years of experience in the insurance industry, helping clients understand their coverage and feel...

michael.png

Jennifer Lemponen

Commercial Lines Specialist

Helping people feel confident and protected is what drew me to the insurance industry. As a Commercial Lines Specialist...

michael.png

Sue Marie Kyko

Commercial Insurance Agent

I’m Sue Marie Kyko, a Commercial Insurance Agent at Humphrey Insurance Agency, proudly serving Jefferson, Ohio, and...

michael.png

Nichole Johnston

Licensed Agent/Notary

Originally from Buffalo, New York, I moved to Ashtabula, Ohio in 2016 and have enjoyed becoming part of the local...

michael.png
bottom of page